The TT or The NW200? Which is Better?

April 17th, 2015 | In: Road Races

In less than four weeks’ time, the first International road race of the season takes place with May’s North West 200 and in what promises to be one of the widest open seasons in years, everything is in place for it to be one of the best meetings ever.

NW200 Superbike PMAKER 14
Stephen Davison - Pacemaker Press International

First held in 1929, the North West – held on an 8.9-mile circuit linking the towns of Portstewart, Coleraine and Portrush on the north coast of Northern Ireland – had a phenomenal rise during the 90s and early 00’s, so much so that it was, arguably, the premier road race in the world as the Isle of Man TT experienced a downturn in fortunes.

With a run of fine weather, superb racing, high profile sponsors like Coca-Cola, and TV coverage never seen before, the North West was able to attract leading short circuit riders from the British Championship – in addition to the established road racers – that put its entry above that of the TT and whilst attendance figures of 150,000 may have been exaggerated somewhat, there can be no denying its popularity soared.

However, the last decade has seen the TT rise from the ashes and the North West take a significant dip as a spate of fatal accidents and poor weather year after year has left its existence teetering, financially, on the brink. The restrictions on road closing orders and increase in TV coverage has essentially had a negative effect as locals know they can see more on their computer screens or on the TV red button than they can trackside and with rain forecast, it’s obvious only the diehards will turn up. It’s safe to say the event is due a week of decent weather and, if it does, it will go some way to re-establishing itself on the calendar and see the fans return.

North West 200 race
Stephen Davison - Pacemaker Press International

Of course, the cream of British road racers will again be in attendance and there are probably more questions than there are answers in terms of who’s going to do what when the lights turn green as never before has an off-season seen so much change.

Michael Dunlop has switched to Milwaukee Yamaha with the Tyco pairing of Guy Martin and William Dunlop foregoing Suzuki in favour of the German BMW machines, the ones which Michael swept all before him in 2014. Gary Johnson and Ian Hutchinson are now Kawasaki mounted in the Superbike class having switched from Honda and Yamaha respectively with young starlet Dean Harrison the official Yamaha rider on the roads. Keith Amor (BMW) and Ryan Farquhar (Kawasaki) are also back in the premier class.

Switching manufacturers always brings with it some form of uncertainty but some things do remain the same and John McGuinness, Conor Cummins and Bruce Anstey all stick with Honda with James Hillier doing likewise at Kawasaki. Meanwhile, multiple North West 200 winners Michael Rutter (13 wins) and Alastair Seeley (12 wins) are two more riders to be BMW-mounted, the latter re-joining the Tyco team for the first time since 2012.

And the good news for all the neutrals is that any one of the aforementioned 14 riders can win and that’s before you’ve thrown the likes of Lee Johnston, Peter Hickman and Dan Kneen into the mix!

Jeremy McWilliams leads KMR Kawasaki team-mate Ryan Farquhar
Stephen Davison - Pacemaker Press International

The TT, in the opinion of the author, will always be the premier road race in the world and its strength in depth is now superior to that of the NW200 but there’s no denying the sight of six to eight riders slipstreaming at speeds in excess of 200mph on the high speed run from Portstewart to Coleraine is one like no other. It’s a scene that isn’t replicated at any other road race and with the final run along the coast road offering similar opportunities, the North West sees action more akin to that at Donington Park as opposed to a street circuit complete with telegraph poles, brick walls and so on.

Two bikes racing with people looking on
Stephen Davison - Pacemaker Press International

Some riders have come in for criticism for seemingly having a short circuit mentality on a road course littered with lethal obstacles and last year saw event organiser Mervyn Whyte issue warnings to the entire field that such riding would not be tolerated. Whilst the numerous chicanes and slow hairpins offer prime overtaking points, even slow corners on the roads can cause serious injury and it’s an issue that everyone will be keeping a close eye on this time around.

After such dismal meetings in recent years, everyone will simply be hoping for a trouble free event this time around and the North West to get firmly back on track.

 

So, if you had to choose from all the Road Races, which would you say is your favourite?

Having started watching motorcycle races all over the world form childhood, Phil Wain has been a freelance motorcycle journalist for 15 years and is features writer for a number of publications including BikeSport News and Classic Racer, having also been a regular contributor to MCN and MCN Sport. He is PR officer for a number of teams and riders at both the British Superbike Championship and International road races, including Smiths Triumph, Quattro Plant Kawasaki, John McGuinness, Ryan Farquhar and Keith Amor. He is also heavily involved with the Isle of Man TT Races, writing official press releases and race reports as well as providing ITV4 with statistical information.

  • dwholmes10

    The one you forgot. Ulster grand prix is the best. I am biased as I was asst clerk of the course for nw200 and the ulster

  • John Close

    The NW200 is far better than the TT the cost for the TT has gone up and up over the years taking it out of the reach for a lot of real fans. The ferry over to the island the cost for B&B’s and a few beers is a rip off.
    The NW200 is proper road racing where riders set off in 2 packs and riders work their way through the pack making it a real spectators sport.
    The TT riders are talented and brave riders
    (Most of them use the NW200 as a warm up for the TT) But the TT has become like all popular sports a way of making money so the real fans cannot follow it live so are left with Sky or one of the other broadcasters with pay per view.
    I will be at the NW200 in May not just for the racing but the great biking roads the crack and the people who make it all worth while. As dwholmes10 wrote earlier the Ulster GP is also another great racing event that is sadly under reported.

  • Stephen Sharpe

    The NW 200 has always outshone the TT. Proper racing, reasonable prices, great roads and brilliant hospitality and easy to get to – whats not to like especially as there is now racing on 2 days. TT has a awful and overpriced ferry service that you need to book nearly a year in advance to guarantee a place. Weather at both can be variable so on that front things are equal. The best bit is the NW 200 has the same no of races as the TT but over 2 days of racing, and the sight of 25 bikes in the pack heading for the first corner – simply awsome eat your heart out TT.

  • ian holme

    I have been attending both for many years and thinks its a big mistake to try and compare the two.
    Great positives and some negatives can be applied to both so lets not give the road racing nay-sayers any ammunition to attack these superb events.
    We should be supporting them all (including the likes of the Tandragee) and enjoying the huge variety of racing experiences that they offer.